Are Noncompete Agreements Dead?

Jamie V. Parker • April 6, 2023

Are Noncompete Agreements Dead?

The Federal Trade Commission is considering a rule that would ban noncompete agreements, which are contracts that prevent employees from working for a competitor after leaving a job. Proponents argue that these agreements stifle competition and limit workers' ability to find new employment opportunities. But opponents say that they're necessary to protect businesses and trade secrets. So, which side is right? Let's dive in and find out.


On January 5, 2023, the Federal Trade Commission released a Notice of Proposed Rulemaking (NPRM) to prohibit employers from imposing noncompete clauses on workers.


Noncompete clauses are contractual terms that prevent workers from working for a competitor or starting a competing business for a certain period of time after leaving their current employer. The FTC's proposed rule would generally prohibit the use of such clauses, including for independent contractors and anyone who is not an employee.


While the proposed rule is not yet in effect, it is important for businesses to be aware of this development and to consider the potential impact it could have on their employment practices. We advise you to review your existing employment contracts and consult with legal counsel to ensure that your agreements are compliant with any new rules or regulations that may be implemented.


The Federal Trade Commission has put forth a proposal to disallow employers from using noncompetes with their employees. This practice is commonplace, but they can take advantage of workers, suppress wages, stifle innovation, and prevent entrepreneurs from launching new businesses. The agency believes that, by prohibiting such a practice, the proposed rule could potentially lead to a $300 billion yearly increase in wages and open up job opportunities for 30 million Americans.


The FTC rule would ban employers from imposing noncompete clauses on their workers, with the aim of increasing job mobility and promoting fair competition.


In addition to prohibiting employers from entering into non-compete clauses with workers starting on the rule’s compliance date, the proposed rule would require employers to rescind existing non-compete clauses no later than the rule’s compliance date. The proposed rule would also require an employer rescinding a non-compete clause to provide notice to the worker that the worker’s non-compete clause is no longer in effect.


To facilitate compliance, the proposed rule would


(1) include model language that would satisfy this notice requirement and

(2) establish a safe harbor whereby an employer would satisfy the rule’s requirement to rescind existing non-compete clauses where it provides the worker with a notice that complies with this notice requirement.


The proposed rule would include a limited exception for non-compete clauses between the seller and buyer of a business. This exception would only be available where the party restricted by the non-compete clause is an owner, member, or partner holding at least a 25% ownership interest in a business entity. Text would clarify that non-compete clauses covered by this exception would remain subject to federal antitrust law as well as all other applicable law.


The FTC has invited public opinion on a proposed rule that has been established on the basis of a preliminary conclusion that noncompetes are an unjust practice of competition, thus contravening Section 5 of the Federal Trade Commission Act. Comments on the proposal can be submitted. The public is encouraged to express their opinion on the proposed rule by submitting comments on the FTC website before April 19, 2023.


This proposed rule from the FTC is in line with their new policy statement to reinvigorate Section 5 of the FTC Act, which prohibits unfair methods of competition. The FTC has recently used this power to prohibit companies from demanding onerous noncompete agreements from their workers, like the Michigan security guard company and its executives. It also ordered two large glass container manufacturers to stop using noncompetes since they block competition and hamper new businesses from finding the right employees. This NPRM and their enforcement actions are part of the agency's broader initiative to use all of their resources to ensure fair competition in the labor market.


Various job levels and industries, such as hairstylists, warehouse workers, physicians, and executives, are required to sign noncompete agreements by their employers. Unfortunately, this is often done through the use of the employer's leverage over the employee. Noncompetes interfere with the competition of labor markets by stopping workers from gaining better chances, as well as stopping employers from hiring the most competent people.


Research indicates that noncompete clauses can impede innovation and business growth in a variety of ways--stopping potential entrepreneurs from establishing competing companies and impeding personnel from bringing new ideas to different firms. This has a negative impact on customers; when there are fewer entrants to the market and greater control, they can be confronted with elevated prices--as seen in the health care sector.


The FTC is taking steps to deal with this issue through the introduction of a general prohibition against the usage of noncompete clauses. This proposed rule would make it a breach of law for an employer to do the following:

  • Try to establish a noncompete agreement with an employee;
  • Maintain a noncompete agreement with a worker; or
  • Lead a worker to believe, in specific conditions, that they are bound by a noncompete.


This regulation would be applicable to both independent contractors and any person employed by a company, regardless of whether they are paid or not. Additionally, employers should revoke any existing noncompete clauses and inform their staff that they are no longer in effect.


The regulation likely will not encompass other work-related limitations, such as non-disclosure agreements. But, should any other employment stipulations be so encompassing that they could be interpreted as noncompetes, then they could be subject to this rule.


Lina M. Khan, Chair of the FTC, declared that having the ability to move from one job to another is a fundamental part of economic liberty and a prosperous economy. Noncompetes prevent people from taking jobs that offer better wages and working conditions. Additionally, this practice also restricts businesses from having access to the talent they require in order to grow and develop. The FTC's proposed rule, if adopted, would eliminate this practice, leading to more dynamism, creativity, and competition in the marketplace. Elizabeth Wilkins, Director of the Office of Policy Planning, commented that the proposed rule would guarantee that companies are not taking advantage of their powerful bargaining power to limit job opportunities and hinder competition.


At the Commission's meeting, votes were cast 3-1 in favor of releasing the Notice of Proposed Rulemaking, which is the FTC's initial step in their rulemaking process. Chair Khan, Commissioner Rebecca Kelly Slaughter, and Commissioner Alvaro Bedoya provided a joint statement. Commissioners Slaughter and Bedoya both issued another statement. Commissioner Christine S. Wilson voted against the decision and provided her own statement.


The FTC will assess the comments and may make modifications to the final rule according to the comments and its further analysis. Link to the FTC for information on this rule https://www.ftc.gov/legal-library/browse/federal-register-notices/non-compete-clause-rulemaking

Common Mistakes Business Owners Make in Divorce (And How to Avoid Them)

February 20, 2025
Common Mistakes Business Owners Make in Divorce (And How to Avoid Them)

Understanding Workplace Discrimination in Ohio: Know Your Rights

February 1, 2025
Understanding Workplace Discrimination in Ohio: Know Your Rights

Who Qualifies for Chapter 11 Bankruptcy in Ohio?

December 2, 2024
Who Qualifies for Chapter 11 Bankruptcy in Ohio?

Your Guide to Hiring a Medical Malpractice Attorney in Ohio

November 16, 2023
Dealing with medical malpractice can be a highly emotional and distressing experience. The thought of putting your health in the hands of a medical professional only to end up with a worsened condition or injury is heart-wrenching. If you have been a victim of medical malpractice in Ohio, hiring a medical malpractice attorney can help you seek the compensation you deserve. In this post, we’ll guide you through the steps of finding the best medical malpractice attorney in Ohio and securing a financial settlement for your losses.  Step 1: Start your search for a medical malpractice attorney in Ohio The first step to securing a successful medical malpractice lawsuit is to find an experienced attorney. You can start your search for a medical malpractice attorney in Ohio by asking for referrals from friends, family, and colleagues. You can also search the internet for reputable lawyers in Ohio who specialize in medical malpractice. Be sure to check the lawyer's qualifications, experience, and reviews from past clients. This will help you make an informed decision about which attorney to hire. Step 2: Schedule an initial consultation Once you have a list of potential medical malpractice attorneys in Ohio, schedule an initial consultation with them. This meeting will give you the chance to discuss your case and evaluate the lawyer’s expertise and experience. A good attorney will ask you detailed questions about your case, medical history, and any evidence you have. They will also explain the legal process, your rights, and the potential compensation you may get. Step 3: Evaluate the attorney's experience and qualifications When hiring a medical malpractice attorney, experience and qualifications matter. Look for an attorney with a good track record of handling medical malpractice cases similar to yours. Check their certifications and professional accreditations to ensure that they have the expertise and qualifications needed to represent your case. Additionally, make sure that the attorney is licensed to practice law in Ohio. Step 4: Discuss fee arrangements Cost is a crucial factor to consider when hiring a medical malpractice attorney. Some attorneys charge an hourly or contingency fee, while others may require a retainer upfront. It's important to discuss fee arrangements with your attorney upfront to avoid surprises. A reputable medical malpractice attorney should be transparent about their fee structure and only get paid if you win the lawsuit. Step 5: Trust your instincts Lastly, trust your instincts when choosing an attorney. You want a lawyer who is professional, honest, and who listens and responds to your concerns. If you feel uncomfortable with the attorney or their approach, it’s better to move on to someone else. A good medical malpractice attorney will have your best interests at heart and will work hard to obtain the compensation you deserve. If you are a victim of medical malpractice in Ohio, hiring a medical malpractice attorney can help you get the compensation you deserve. Finding the right attorney requires careful consideration of their qualifications, experience, and professionalism. By following the steps outlined in this post, you can select the best attorney for your case and achieve a favorable outcome. Remember, you have a legal right to pursue compensation for your losses, and a qualified attorney can help you navigate the legal system and seek justice.

Is Aggravated Assault a Felony in Ohio?

October 30, 2023
Assault, in any degree or form, can have severe legal consequences. In Ohio, aggravated assault is considered a serious crime that can result in severe prison sentences. In this blog post, we will take a closer look at the legal definition of aggravated assault, the penalties associated with this crime, and how it differs from other states in the United States.  Aggravated assault is a type of assault that involves the use of a deadly weapon or the intent to cause severe bodily harm. In Ohio, aggravated assault is classified as a felony of the fourth degree and can lead to up to 18 months of imprisonment and fines which can go up to $5000. Cincinnati law recognizes different degrees of felony that take into account the gravity of crime committed by the convict. Essentially, it is a more severe crime than simple assault, which often results in only misdemeanor charges. Other states in the United States have different criteria to classify aggravated assault. For example, in some states, assault with a deadly weapon is considered a separate class from aggravated assault, which only requires an intent to cause bodily injury and not necessarily an intent to kill. Some states also differentiate based on the severity of bodily harm caused. Therefore, it is important to understand the relevant laws of the state in which you reside. Aggravated assault in Ohio can be punishable with harsher penalties in certain cases such as, if the assault results in serious bodily harm or the victim is a public servant, such as a law enforcement officer. In these circumstances, the crime is elevated to a third-degree felony. The penalty for third-degree crimes in Ohio ranges from one to five years in prison and fines ranging from $2500 to $10,000. In some instances, you could find yourself charged with multiple offenses related to an incident of aggravated assault. For example, you could also face charges for carrying an illegal weapon or other drug-related offenses simultaneously. These combined offenses can lead to a more complicated legal procedure and more heft penalties. Aggravated assault is a serious offense that can lead to severe legal consequences. Ohio considers this crime a felony of the fourth degree and can result in up to 18 months of imprisonment and $5000 in fines. However, penalties can vary based on additional factors such as the severity of the injury or if a public servant was involved. In other US States, aggravated assault may have different classifications and penalties, highlighting the importance of understanding local law. If you have been charged with aggravated assault, it is crucial to connect with a Cincinnati criminal defense attorney to fully understand your legal rights. Remember, the quality of your defense can decide whether or not you are found guilty, and that is why it’s important to have a professional with experience guide you through the legal process.

Understanding the Financial Implications of Foreclosure for Ohio Residents

By Steven Heimberger • September 29, 2023
Buying your first home is always an exciting time, but it can quickly turn into a nightmare if things don't go according to plan. One of the worst-case scenarios that homeowners fear is foreclosure. Foreclosure can have serious financial implications that go beyond simply losing your home. In this blog post, we'll discuss what happens to your down payment, whether you get your money back if your home gets foreclosed on, and other important financial considerations for Ohio residents. 1. What happens to your down payment in a foreclosure?  When you're buying a house, you'll typically make a down payment to secure the purchase. But what happens to that down payment if your home goes into foreclosure? Unfortunately, in the case of foreclosure, you will not get your down payment back. Once you've made the down payment, it goes towards the purchase price of the house, and you won't be able to recover it if the house is foreclosed. 2. Will you get your money back if your home gets foreclosed on? If you're facing foreclosure, you're probably wondering if you can get any of your money back. Unfortunately, the answer is usually no. When a house is foreclosed on, the bank takes possession of the property and sells it to recoup their losses. Any money made from the sale goes toward paying off the mortgage, and any remainder is paid to the homeowner. However, in most cases, the sale of the property won't be enough to cover the outstanding mortgage, so the homeowner won't get any money back. 3. The impact of foreclosure on your credit score In addition to losing your home and any down payment you've made, foreclosure can have a severe impact on your credit score. A foreclosure will stay on your credit report for up to seven years and can make it challenging to obtain credit in the future. If you're considering purchasing another home after foreclosure, you'll likely have to pay higher interest rates on your mortgage, and you may have trouble qualifying for a loan at all. 4. Foreclosure alternatives If you're struggling to keep up with your mortgage payments, there may be alternatives to foreclosure that you can explore. One option is a loan modification, which can allow you to renegotiate the terms of your mortgage to make it more affordable. Another option is a short sale, where you sell your home for less than the outstanding mortgage and the bank agrees to forgive the remaining debt. Foreclosure is a difficult and stressful experience, and the financial implications can be severe. If you're facing foreclosure, you should consult with an experienced attorney to understand your options and make the best decisions possible for your financial future. Remember, there are alternatives to foreclosure, and taking action sooner rather than later can help you protect your credit score and minimize your losses.

Chapter 7 vs. Chapter 13 Bankruptcy: What You Need to Know

July 5, 2023
Chapter 7 vs. Chapter 13 Bankruptcy: What You Need to Know

Understanding the Rights of Creditors in Bankruptcy Matters

April 21, 2023
Understanding the Rights of Creditors in Bankruptcy Matters

Understanding Chapter 13 Bankruptcy: What Ohio Residents Need to Know

March 28, 2023
Understanding Chapter 13 Bankruptcy: What Ohio Residents Need to Know

What Are The Benefits of Filing For Chapter 7 Bankruptcy

By Steven Heimberger • January 16, 2023
Bankruptcy occurs when a person or a business is unable to pay their debts or meet other financial obligations. It is a legal method for getting relief from the situation. Bankruptcy is typically the last option for people who are unable to renegotiate payments for loans or make other arrangements with their creditors. Though it stops the collections processes, it may require you to liquidate your assets, and it will affect your credit score. That said, the goal of bankruptcy is to give yourself a fresh, debt-free start and a chance to rebuild your credit. Types of Bankruptcy There are several types of bankruptcy: Chapter 7 uses a liquidation process to pay off creditors using the debtor's assets and other available funds. This option is most common for individuals. Chapter 11 allows businesses (and some individuals) to restructure their debt so that they can pay it off without liquidation. Chapter 13 is another restructured debt option for individuals with regular income who will be able to pay off their debt but need different terms than they currently have. Most individuals will opt for Chapter 7 because it is the only practical option available to them. Though it is possible to file the necessary documents yourself in  Akron, Ohio  , you can also hire a bankruptcy lawyer to assist with the process. How Chapter 7 Works The process of Chapter 7 bankruptcy starts when you file a petition with a bankruptcy court. These courts are all part of the federal legal system, so the process is similar no matter where you live. The entire process can take about four to six months. Once your petition gets accepted, the court issues a stay to your creditors. This order requires them to stop collections activities. A trustee will take over your case. They will oversee the process, communicate with creditors, and liquidate your assets. You must submit supporting documents to show your assets and income. You attend a meeting of creditors during which all your creditors can ask questions and request documentation. Creditors can, but rarely, attend the meeting. You must complete financial management courses during the bankruptcy process. Your debts won't be fully discharged until you do and submit evidence to the trustee. The trustee will oversee the liquidation of your assets and the distribution of proceeds to your creditors. Once you complete all requirements, the debt is discharged and creditors can no longer pursue you for additional repayment. However, it can take up to 10 years to remove the bankruptcy from your credit report. The Advantages of Chapter 7 Bankruptcy Most debtors focus on the negative aspects of bankruptcy, such as liquidation and the impact on credit scores. However, bankruptcy also brings benefits. It is essential to understand these advantages to help decide whether chapter 7 is best for you. Chapter 7 bankruptcy brings an automatic stay on all unsecured debt. Creditors must immediately stop contacting you for repayment. If you complete the process correctly, they will never contact you after you file for bankruptcy. You will have a clean financial slate after the discharge of your debts. Unlike other forms of bankruptcy, which require repayment plans, chapter 7 completely dismisses all debt and gives the debtor a new start. The process is much faster than other bankruptcy options. The process, from filing to discharge, usually takes six months or less. You will get rid of unsecured, consumer debt. Credit card debt, hospital bills, and personal loans will get discharged after liquidation. Chapter 7 allows you to keep necessities exempt from liquidation. This property may include your home, vehicle, or tools necessary for your job. Exemptions can vary, so it is typically best to ask an attorney about claiming them. You will take a financial planning course, which can help you set up a plan for the future and avoid excessive debt. Filing for bankruptcy prevents creditors from taking any further legal action against you for non-payment. Future income and assets acquired after bankruptcy are not affected by your debt. You can immediately start building a savings account. You typically deal directly with a trustee instead of appearing in court, making the chapter 7 process less stressful than other options. A lawyer is allowed to help you with the bankruptcy process and can argue on your behalf for exemptions or other issues involved in chapter 7. Qualifications for Chapter 7 Bankruptcy You need to meet specific requirements to file for chapter 7. This option is available to individuals or small businesses. Your average monthly income for the previous six months needs to be less than the average income for a similar-sized household in the same state. Alternatively, you could pass a means test to prove that you do not have disposable income to pay creditors. You have not filed for bankruptcy in eight years (six years for chapter 13 bankruptcy). If a court dismissed your previous bankruptcy petition, you must wait six months (181 days) before trying again. You can support claims of assets with financial documentation. You can complete a credit counseling course. Chapter 7 is best for unsecured debts, like credit card debt. With secured loans, the lender has the right to repossess your property if you do not make payments, so chapter 7 may not provide relief in these situations. Exemptions for Chapter 7 Also, some types of debt are exempt from discharge during bankruptcy. These include: Child support and alimony payments Student loans Court fees and fines Taxes (with some exceptions) Debts from accidents for which you were liable Fees for condo or homeowner associations How an Attorney Can Help with Chapter 7 Bankruptcy You can technically file for chapter 7 bankruptcy without an attorney. However, the process has long-term financial consequences, so you should seek legal advice if you have any concerns, questions, or uncertainties about the process. If you need to defend your petition or claims, a lawyer in  Akron, Ohio  can represent you. The US Court System website strongly recommends consulting a lawyer during bankruptcy. Reach out to us if you are considering filing for bankruptcy.
More Posts
Share by: